Nightmare Magazine

ADVERT: Lightspeed + Nightmare LIVE on Kickstarter

Advertisement

Nonfiction

The H Word–The Final Girl Fifty Years Later

“I take back every bit of energy I every gave you.”

– Nancy Thompson

For decades, horror fans were trained to spot her.

She wasn’t always the prettiest, but she was responsible, loyal, and polite. She carried her books against her chest, worried about her grades, and was always home by curfew. The “good girl” by the moral arithmetic governing slashers in the 1970s, 1980s, and early 1990s, while masked psychos and possessed killers stalked the streets of her suburbs or summer camp, her friends drank, wore their skirts too short, had sex, and defied their parents, but with deadly consequences.

But while those same friends were picked off one by one, she endured. She screamed and scrambled and struggled through one narrow escape after the next until, finally, bruised, terrified, and soaked in blood, she limped away from the killer one last time. We watched her—eyes glued to the screen or the page—staggering toward the sunrise as she emerged as the lone survivor.

In her book Men, Women and Chainsaws: Gender in the Modern Film, Carol J. Clover gave her a name: the Final Girl. She’s had other names through the years. Laurie Strode. Jade Daniels. Sidney Prescott. Yet, despite her new iterations or seeming reincarnations, the essence of her remains: When everyone else is dead, she is still standing.

Final Girls have become symbols of survival and resilience in horror. And we have watched them relive their cycles of trauma again and again, repeating patterns of abuse as they are pursued, cornered, and bloodied only to emerge victorious once more with more scars, both internal and external. Then we wait for the killer to rise again, knowing the Final Girl will be waiting.

But fifty odd years after the archetype was given its name and definition, something remarkable happened.

The Final Girl managed to survive long enough to evolve.

From Disney Princess to Big Bitch Energy

For years, the Final Girl was unfairly reduced to the horror version of a Disney princess—a passive heroine whose defining characteristic was simply having a moral compass that pointed near enough to True North to outlive everyone else.

In fairness, that reading has never been entirely accurate. While early slashers frequently linked female sexuality and teenage rebellion with death where the Final Girl was positioned as the exception, she was not necessarily rewarded for being heroic so much as spared for being othered. And even some of the earliest Final Girls were displaying resilience and adaptability. Nancy Thompson, exhausted and saddled with the most useless adults of perhaps any franchise, didn’t hide from Freddy. She engineered a system of complicated booby traps that would have earned her valuable extra credit in her AP Physics and Chemistry classes. Ellen Ripley redefined an entire genre of horror/SF by subverting nearly all the tropes of damsel in distress by being commanding, direct, and the ultimate badass, but did so in a role that had originally been written with a man in mind.

Still, even with outliers, the archetype carried limitations. The Final Girl trended white, cisgender, young, able-bodied, and conventionally attractive. Her survival was framed as “accidental” rather than through agency, again offering us that implicit promise buried inside a Disneyfication formula that if we just work hard and are pretty and “good,” we will be rewarded.

Modern horror has challenged every one of these assumptions.

The Final Girl is no longer exclusively the quiet, white girl living in a gentrified, HOA neighborhood with no problems bigger than which boy will ask her to prom (before the whole killer thing, obviously). Instead, she is Naru in Prey, a Comanche woman who knows her value is as a warrior rather than a healer and who stalks, confronts, and defeats a Predator where all others fail. Or she is Brianna Cartwright, summoning the mythological Candyman while navigating institutional racism. She is Jordyn Monroe in The Scammer, who knows a cult is forming in the dorm of her HBCU, unwilling to back down when it would be easier. She is bisexual Sundae Valentine from Body Count, trying to win both her squad’s Slut Cup and a pretty guitarist’s heart while avoiding paying up on a supernatural debt.

The Final Girl has become less interested in being “good” and much more interested in being alive.

And that is no accident.

From Accident to Intention

Classic horror positioned survival as something that happened to the Final Girl. Slashers of the ’70s and ’80s often ended with rescue arriving from the outside, albeit at the last possible moment. The handsome man charging in right as the knife was going down, a passing truck on the otherwise empty highway, or the lone doctor nobody believed arriving with a gun just in time. As with anything, there were exceptions, but more often than not, our scream queens outran more than they overpowered.

When we moved into the ’90s, we began to see Final Girls directly confronting the monster or outwitting the killer. They didn’t just set booby traps, they took up a weapon and became their own rescuer, but the weapons were often situational, resulting in the Final Girl grabbing the nearest coat hanger or knitting needle and fighting out of necessity alone.

The shift to intention was subtle, but not insignificant. Rather than asking, “How do I get away?” the Final Girl started asking, “How do I kill it?” This meant they were not enduring, but deciding. Instead of Final Girls being “accidental survivors” or just the last ones standing, their survival became an intentional act. The modern Final Girl has her own ax, chainsaw, or shotgun. They don’t escape the house and keep running; they walk back inside, and that reversal fundamentally changed the power dynamic.

The monster no longer loses because someone got lucky, but because someone hunts it back.

From Victim to Veteran

But perhaps the most significant change in the Final Girl has been her experience. We’ve allowed her to grow with us rather than keeping her forever young and forever perfect. She has been allowed to age. The archetype no longer belongs exclusively to the young. Time and gravity have finally been allowed to touch the Final Girl. She has crow’s feet and bad knees and—if she’s lucky—a 401K to pay for her therapy. She’s had a few failed relationships and maybe children of her own. Most importantly, she has a past full of experience and trauma.

Final Girls are veterans who know what monsters look like and know the cost of survival. A truth that goes beyond fiction when survivors of violence carry that trauma for life. Something that horror franchises like Halloween, Scream, and The Indian Lake trilogy do exceptionally well is show that the story is no longer simply about surviving one terrible night, but living with that night for years afterward. Final Girls who live to see a sequel—like survivors of real-life violence—are complex characters with PTSD and anxiety who struggle to “move on” because there is no moving on for a Final Girl just like there is no “before.” She knows the killer comes back again and again because she knows how the genre works.

She knows horrors persist.

But so will she.

Final Form

Her evolution mirrors, in many ways, the evolution of horror. Earlier slashers often focused on punishment rather than consequence. Modern horror is increasingly interested in empathy and asking what violence and trauma does to a person. What is the cost of survival? What happens when a person who escapes a monster must return to the same community that failed to protect her in the first place? What happens when she doesn’t have the luxury of being afraid anymore?

She survived because she has changed. She grew angrier and more resolved. She learned the rules and she isn’t waiting for someone to save her.

She is waiting for the monster.

What’s more, she has become the thing the monsters should have been afraid of all along.

(Author’s Note: For the sake of word count and recognition, I’m sticking to the term Final Girl and using primarily she/her pronouns. But I’d like to acknowledge that we no longer have to have a Final “Girl” and are in a time when we can have a Final He/They/Them. The archetype no longer belongs exclusively to women.)

Enjoyed this article? Consider supporting us via one of the following methods:

Tanya Pell

Tanya Pell is a narcoleptic horror author who drinks bougie coffee and lives in the American South. She is the Bram Stoker Award-nominated author of This B Just Won’t Die! and Her Wicked Roots. Her short fiction can be found in collections like Fever Dreams, Mother Knows Best, Obsolescence, and more.