Nightmare Magazine

ADVERTISEMENT: Slashic Horror Press, the Best in Queer Horror

Advertisement

Fiction

Eight Ball


CW: none.


There’s an eye in the back of my husband’s head.

It opens only after he’s fallen asleep, lid splitting silent as a dream in the night.

My husband’s eyes are amber, no brighter than a penny in the sun. The eye on the back of his head is different. It looks out at me through his dark hair, pupil white and glowing, drifting in a sea-dark jelly.

The first time I saw it, I thought it was just another nightmare. Anxiety and paranoia have always danced through my head, day and night. Seeing movement on his head, faced away from me, catching a glimpse of that lighthouse eye before shutting my own, rolling over, praying . . . for a moment, I wondered if I had brought it to life, my fear warping reality, conjuring it, even.

Surely just a nightmare, no more than that.

But one evening, hunkered under my booklight and regretting affogato, I heard a wet parting. Glanced over, down. Saw the pupil float up, staring at me. It was not round, like I thought. Triangular, it bored into me.

I went very still, breath shallow, rapid. Closed my book. Even when I turned the light off, yes, the secret eye emitted a little glow, white as snow.

“Are you real?” I barely heard myself ask it. It could’ve just been a thought in my mind. If the eye hadn’t reacted.

Around and around, the eye spun like a top, whirling faster than I could track. When it came to a stop, a word was written on the white of the pupil: Yes.

Every night since, I’ve asked questions, things I’d never dream of asking my husband in the light of day.

Does he still love me?

Why is he so scared?

Can I help?

Without a doubt.

Better not tell you now.

Ask again later.

That’s the one that comes up the most. Even in sleep, he refuses vulnerability. Days and weeks and star-endingly long years spent tight-lipped, strained, sad; it seemed our nights had become the same.

But where my husband shuts down, at least the eye tries.

At least the eye is okay not knowing, not pretending. It sets boundaries when a question isn’t the right one or it’s not the right time and I respect them. My husband could learn a thing or two from that gaze of his that only looks at me; me, and nothing else.

I’ve tried talking with him about it and like everything else too real, too important, he won’t engage. Moves away to topics he has control over, to things that bring him joy, not uncertainty. He has fashioned armor from banality and small talk and those deep fears, guarding his heart, even from me.

Well, I’m tired of being ignored, held at arm’s length. So, I’ve told the eye my plan. It listened with liquid patience. When I asked if it was a good idea, it said, Signs point to yes.

I’m going to do it. I’ll roll over and sleep on my side. Face away from him tonight and every night, hoping, praying that when he rolls over to hold me or ask where I went, he will see what I’ve seen so many, many nights now: an eye of my own.

I hope there will be an eye on the back of my head, bright, unyielding, inescapable.

I hope it will look at him through my tangle of dark hair, unblinking, waiting, ready.

I hope it will tell him the truth he refuses to hear, the kind that gets in, burrows, bursts him free of this armor.

Outlook good?

We’ll find out.

Together.

Martin Cahill

Martin Cahill is a science fiction and fantasy writer living in NYC and works as the marketing and publicity manager for Erewhon Books. He’s a graduate of the Clarion Workshop of 2014 and a member of the NYC-based writing group Altered Fluid. You can find his fiction in Lightspeed Magazine, Fireside Magazine, Beneath Ceaseless Skies and other places. His short story “Godmeat” appeared in The Best American Science Fiction and Fantasy 2019, and he is part of the writing team for Batman: The Blind Cut, out now from Realm. Martin also writes, and has written, book reviews and essays for Tor.com, Book Riot, Strange Horizons, and the Barnes and Noble Science Fiction & Fantasy Blog. You can find him online at @mcflycahill90.

Discord header
ADVERTISEMENT: Robot Wizard Zombie Crit! Newsletter (for Lightspeed, Nightmare, and John Joseph Adams' Anthologies)
Keep up with Nightmare, Lightspeed, and John Joseph Adams' anthologies—as well as SF/F news and reviews, discussion of RPGs, and other fun stuff.

Delivered to your inbox once a week. Subscribers also get a free ebook anthology for signing up.
Join the Nightmare Discord server to chat and share opinions with fellow Nightmare readers.

Discord is basically like a cross between a instant messenger and an old-school web forum.

Join to chat about horror (and SF/F) short stories, books, movies, tv, games, and more!